The Yarra Planning Coalition is an alliance of community groups and individual residents based in the City of Yarra formed to coordinate advocacy and submissions on local urban planning and development issues.

Dear Sally and Richard,

Thank you for your letter and for setting out the Yarra Planning Coalition’s concerns so clearly. I’m standing as an independent, so these are my own positions rather than a party line. Brunswick has been the epicentre of higher-density development for twenty years, and I think the lessons from that experience are being ignored in the State’s current approach.

1. Returning planning decision-making to Councils. Yes. The State has been steadily eroding the influence of local councils and residents’ rights. Applications are exempted from review, height and setback requirements can be waived or varied, and the Minister has replaced the council as the responsible authority. Residents and councils can agree a development is inappropriate and still not shift the outcome. I would return decisions on most developments to Councils, with State intervention limited to projects of genuine state significance.

2. Ending or reducing the Development Facilitation Program and Fast Track. Yes. Fast-track assessment is increasingly the norm, with objection rights reduced or removed. I’m particularly concerned by “scorecard” assessment, where local planning schemes, traffic, social and environmental outcomes and amenity impacts are treated as secondary or ignored. I would significantly wind back Fast Track and restore proper assessment of local impacts. I also support properly funding and empowering IBAC, so that oversight of planning decisions has teeth.

3. Removing the Planning Minister’s additional powers under the 2026 Act. Yes. At a minimum, I would require published reasons for ministerial decisions and restore review rights. Residents also deserve jargon-free explanations of planning changes that affect them.

4. Maintaining Heritage Overlay Areas in Merri-bek and Yarra. Yes. We will look back at this boom the way we look back at the loss of the Hoffman Brickworks, Pentridge and the Coles Book Arcade, and wonder how we let our built heritage slip away.

5 and 6. Train and Tram Activity Centres heights, including Sydney Road. Appropriate heights are contextual and change over time, so I don’t think any single number can be fixed forever. But heights should be set in planning controls, developed with Councils and communities, rather than being decided case by case by the State. Where the State’s changes bypass local height and setback policies, I don’t think they serve the inner north.

7. Mandatory height and setback controls in Built Form Overlays. I support height and setback controls sitting in the local planning scheme, and I oppose the power to waive or vary them. They should be updated through a proper community and strategic process as circumstances change.

8. Removing the designation of all of Yarra as an Activity Centre. Activity centres should be determined by proximity to transport, work and services, not applied across a whole municipality.

9. Funding and delivering infrastructure before density increases. Yes. This is a core part of my housing platform. Government must match investment in childcare, public transport, roads, sporting and recreational facilities and open space to population growth. Those are already pinch points in Brunswick. Ratepayers also shouldn’t be left paying for upgrades that mainly lift the value of nearby development sites.

10. Maintaining or increasing green space and canopy. Yes. I’m part of Brunswick Communities for Nature, and I support more urban greening, with a stronger focus on biodiversity and on the needs of children and families.

11. Public and social housing share in inner Melbourne. Yes, and I’d go further. Victoria’s social housing share has fallen from about 3.6% in 2011 to about 3.2%, the lowest in the country, while roughly 65,000 people wait for a home. I want real public housing: publicly owned and publicly run, not community housing or public-private partnerships that move responsibility and scrutiny away from government. I oppose selling surplus public land for private development when it could be used to build public housing. I also oppose demolishing existing public housing without a firm commitment to replace every dwelling and keep residents in place.

12. Development levies and affordable housing. I share your goal, but I come at the mechanism differently. I don’t believe permit conditions are a reliable way to deliver affordable housing. Project feasibility suffers, outcomes depend on the ongoing capacity of housing agencies, and recent examples show promises can be walked back. My concern is the same as yours: the State has traded extra height for “affordable” housing commitments that may not be delivered. If the State wants social housing, it should fund and build it. Where developers are required to contribute, I would want the contribution to be transparent and spent on publicly owned and controlled public housing in the same area.

I’d welcome the chance to meet before the 28 November election.

Yours sincerely,

Mel Yuan


Dear Candidate for Brunswick

Planning Intentions

To help us decide our vote we are interested to know Candidates intentions. Attached is a summary of our concerns based on Yarra Planning Coalition issues We would like to know your position (or your party’s position if different) on the following questions:

  1. Returning planning decision-making to Councils?
  2. Ending, or significantly reducing, the Development Facilitation Program, particularly the Fast Track processes?
  3. Removing the additional powers given to the Planning Minister by the Planning Amendment (Better Decisions Made Faster) Act 2026?
  4. Maintaining existing Heritage Overlay Areas in Merri-bek and City of Yarra?
  5. Reversing the recent planning changes made through the Train and Tram Activity Centres Program to return heights to previously Council approved Design and Development Overlays, including in and around Sydney Road, Brunswick.
  6. Or if 5 is not supported: significantly reducing heights in activity centres adjacent to residential areas particularly in Housing Choice and Transport Zone 2 (ie stepping down to low-rise).
  7. Enabling, or requiring, mandatory height and setback controls in Built Form Overlays in local Planning Schemes.
  8. Removing the designation of the entire City of Yarra as an Activity Centre?
  9. Ensuring funding and delivery of infrastructure prior to density increases?
  10. Maintaining or increasing green space and green canopy?
  11. Maintaining or increasing the current overall %age of Public/Social Housing in Inner Melbourne?
  12. Development levies – ensure affordable housing provided within development –ie  not allowing cash in lieu levy except in exceptional circumstances?

We would be happy to meet with you to clarify or discuss these issues. 

Yours sincerely

Sally and Richard

Concerns (Yarra Planning Coalition)

  1. Restore democracy – Our community must have meaningful input to planning for their area because it leads to better decisions and stronger more engaged communities. The new planning regime is anti-democratic, autocratic and decision-making has been taken from Councils and community. Recent ‘consultation’ has been insulting.
  • Why should the Minister be able to ride roughshod over plans, such as Design and Development Overlays, that the Council and community have worked together over months and sometimes years to put in place? Even very recently announced Built Form Overlays have been completely ignored in recent permit decisions.
  • Who is benefiting from land price uplift or betterment (windfall gains) arising from planning decisions by the Fast-Track processes?
  • Who knows our areas best – developers? DTP planners? or our Council planners and the community?
  • Why should developers have their own system and the ear of the Minister?
  • The planning system needs probity – Without transparency, integrity and fairness, community trust in government breaks down. Decisions currently are being made behind closed doors, creating the perception and potential for corruption (as per Operation Sandon report). Large development decisions should be fully visible to all.
  • What are the community benefits of fast-tracking residential development approvals? Expedited permits do not guarantee immediate construction, sites lie dormant or on-sold at a huge premium where heights have been increased. Fast-tracking inflates land values and fuels speculation.
  • Who is benefitting from the land price uplift when heights are increased?
  • Why should developers have ready access to Ministerial intervention?
  • What accountability is there for decisions made?
  • Liveable communities – Thriving communities need good design and infrastructure.
  • Where are the plans for new infrastructure: parks? schools? childcare and kindergartens? health services? sport and recreation infrastructure?
  • Do we care about protecting access to sunlight, walkability, overlooking and overshadowing?
  • Do we value the character of our streets and neighbourhoods, the heritage areas, street patterns (laneways) and fine-grained lots, and the distinct neighbourhood character and identity?
  • Do we care about retaining our distinctive quirky shopping strips and independent retailers that underpin the economic success of the City of Yarra?
  • Build more social and affordable housing to maintain diverse communities and deliver it for the people who need social and affordable housing in areas where they need to live. More housing without affordable and social housing only caters for wealthy local and offshore investors.
  • Where are the new affordable and social housing to be built?
  • Why should developers be able to opt to pay a levy instead of delivering more social and affordable housing?
  • Why has the affordable housing mechanism in the updated Planning & Environment Act (1987) not been proclaimed – Section 6(6)(ja) and (2AA).
  • Why is much needed public housing being demolished, particularly in the light of the recent UN report and when there are very good options for building upgrades which keep residents in place?

Additional point – Heritage (not included in Yarra Planning Coalition paper)

Protect heritage and maintain Heritage Overlay Areas within the planning scheme.

It is important to understand that Heritage Overlay Areas do not prevent development. Our heritage areas are a much-loved part of inner Melbourne. They also provide economic and social benefits. As the City of Melbourne says: ‘Distinct character and city identity is vitally important to attracting visitors and investment…Heritage places help make cities more people-centred, more sustainable and more resilient to changing economies, ensuring the amenity, human scale and tactility of the city.’

  • Heritage areas and patterns of development are not just important as ‘heritage’ links to the past; they provide attractive fine grain distinctive neighbourhoods, with visual charm, character, details, traditional craftsmanship, period facades and features, distinctive styles and rich visual depth.
  • Sense of place and identity.
  • Attractive heritage areas are an invaluable economic asset for Melbourne: attracting tourism; underpinning our liveability and our global ‘brand’; and a vital attractor for high end innovation workers and business. Authentic cultural experience.
  • Heritage and sense of place play a large part in social cohesion which in itself has economic value.
  • Adaptive reuse of older buildings is environmentally sound practice.

Leave a Reply