Return Prisons to Public Hands

Running prisons is a core responsibility of government. The power to deprive a person of their liberty should remain directly accountable to the public through democratic government, not delegated to private corporations.

Private prisons were introduced on the promise of greater efficiency, better rehabilitation outcomes and improved value for taxpayers. Yet concerns about performance and accountability remain. In 2018, the Victorian Auditor-General’s Office found that Victoria’s assessment of private prison contract extensions lacked sufficient rigour to demonstrate value for money. In 2026, the Auditor-General found that Ravenhall Correctional Centre’s overall reoffending outcomes were similar to other Victorian men’s prisons and fell short of performance targets. In 2025, the Victorian Ombudsman identified serious misconduct by staff at a privately operated prison and scrutinised both the operator’s response and the adequacy of government oversight. Taxpayers deserve evidence, transparency and accountability when essential public services are outsourced. [audit.vic.gov.au], [audit.vic.gov.au], [ombudsman.vic.gov.au], [parliament…vic.gov.au]

I support a phased transition of privately operated prisons back into public management as existing contracts expire.

I advocate for:

  • Returning privately operated prisons to public management when current contracts come to an end.
  • Strengthening transparency and public reporting of prison costs, safety outcomes and rehabilitation performance.
  • Reinvesting funds currently directed toward private profit into rehabilitation, mental health, education and drug treatment programs.
  • Improving workforce training, accountability and professional standards across the corrections system.
  • Prioritising evidence-based programs that reduce reoffending and improve community safety.

This is not about being soft or tough on crime. It is about ensuring that a fundamental responsibility of government is exercised in the public interest.

The case for prison privatisation rests on claims of efficiency and value for money. Yet independent reviews have repeatedly raised questions about whether those promises have been fulfilled. When government cannot clearly demonstrate superior value for taxpayers, deliver materially better outcomes, or provide robust accountability arrangements, the justification for private prison operation becomes weaker. Prisons should be run for community safety, rehabilitation and public accountability, not shareholder returns.

Sources

  1. Victorian Auditor-General’s Office, Safety and Cost Effectiveness of Private Prisons (2018) found shortcomings in the assessment of private prison contract extensions and concluded that the value-for-money assessment process lacked sufficient rigour. [audit.vic.gov.au]
  2. Victorian Auditor-General’s Office, Ravenhall Correctional Centre: Rehabilitating and Reintegrating Prisoners – Part 2 (2026) found Ravenhall’s overall reoffending results were similar to other Victorian adult male prisons and fell short of performance targets. [audit.vic.gov.au]
  3. Victorian Ombudsman, ‘That’s assault mate’: Investigation into alleged misconduct in a private prison and how it was handled (2025) found a supervisor at Ravenhall used unreasonable force against a prisoner and examined the adequacy of both operator and government oversight. [ombudsman.vic.gov.au], [parliament…vic.gov.au]

Leave a Reply